Buyela kuzo zonke izikhala
Izibonelelo ze-akhawunti yasebhange vs. imfundo yezezimali
AI-generated illustration: a participant completing a financial literacy assessment.

Izibonelelo ze-akhawunti yasebhange vs. imfundo yezezimali

Yize kwesinye isikhathi izinga locwaningo kwezomnotho lingaba phezulu kakhulu, ngikhuthazwa ucwaningo oluningi oluthakazelisayo engilubona kozakwethu kulo mkhakha. Iphepha engisanda kulithola ngababhali uShawn Cole, uThomas Sampson, noBilal Zia (Cole et al. 2011) lisebenzisa isivivinyo esilawulwa ngokungahleliwe ukutadisha imiphumela yemfundo yezezimali kanye nemiphumela yesibonelelo se-akhawunti yasebhange ehlanganiswe ndawonye. Lokhu kwavusa intshisekelo yami. Ngokusobala kungaba lula uma imfundo yezezimali iyisisombululo esihle kakhulu futhi okuwukuphela kwesixazululo sokukhulisa ukufakwa kwezezimali, kepha ukuqeqeshwa kwami nokucabanga kwami okubucayi kungitshela ukuthi lokhu akusoze kwaba yiqiniso. Kulokhu, bekuyiphepha elidala, kepha kuyangijabulisa ukubona ukuthi abanye ababhali ezincwadini zezomnotho babekhuluma ngemibuzo enzima ehlobene nokufunda nokubhala kwezezimali. Yini abayitholile? Yini eyayinemikhawulo neminye imibuzo ehambisana nokuthola?


Ababhali bafunde umongo wase-Indonesia olinganisa amakhaya angama-3,360 emizaneni eyi-112 phakathi kukaJulayi noDisemba 2007, kanye nesampula yaseNdiya futhi ethathwe eduze ne-Ahmedabad, eGujarat. Iqembu elilodwa alitholanga ukungenelela nhlobo (ukulawula), iqembu elilodwa lathola izipesheli zama-akhawunti asebhange axhaswayo (ukwelashwa 1), iqembu elilodwa lathola imfundo eyisisekelo yezezimali (ukwelashwa 2), futhi iqembu elilodwa lathola kokubili okunikezwayo kwama-akhawunti asebhange axhaswayo kanye nemfundo eyisisekelo yezezimali (ukwelashwa 3). Ababhali babehlose ukukala ukuthi kungenzeka kanjani ukuthi ababambiqhaza babambe i-akhawunti yasebhange ngemuva kokuthola enye yezokwelashwa.


Adults seated at wooden desks in a village classroom while an instructor stands beside a whiteboard
Umdwebo okhiqizwa yi-AI: iseshini yemfundo yezezimali yasedolobhaneni e-Indonesia.

Ababhali bathola ukuthi ukufunda nokubhala kwezezimali kuphansi e-Indonesia lapho cishe ama-52% wemibuzo ekuhlolweni okujwayelekile kokufunda nokubhala kwezezimali iphendulwa kahle. E-India, abantu baphendule ngokunembile kuphela kuma-34% wemibuzo yokufunda nokubhala kwezezimali. Kunzima ukuthola idatha efanayo kusukela ngaleso sikhathi esivela e-United States, kepha idatha eqhathaniswa kakhulu engikwazile ukuyithola ivela embikweni we-Financial Literacy Around the World olinganisa i-United States njenge-57% yabantu abanolwazi lwezezimali, i-Indonesia njenge-32% yabantu abanolwazi lwezezimali, ne-India njenge-24% yabantu abanolwazi lwezezimali (Klapper et al. 2015).


Imithelela yesikhathi esifushane

Ukugxila kulolu cwaningo uqobo, ababhali bathola ukuthi abantu abanikezwa isikhuthazo sama-rupees ayi-125000 bakhuphule ukusetshenziswa kwama-akhawunti asebhange cishe ngo-13.7% eNdiya ngenkathi e-Indonesia isibonelelo se- $ 14 US sibe nomthelela ofanayo. Imfundo yezezimali iyodwa ayizange ikhuphule kakhulu isabelo sabantu abavule i-akhawunti yasebhange esemthethweni.


A crowded bank branch with customers queuing at teller windows and others waiting on benches
OLUNYE UDABA: Amakhasimende ahamba emgqeni egatsheni lasebhange e-Indonesia

Imithelela yesikhathi eside

Ababhali bathola ukuthi ama-akhawunti asebhange anamathele esikhathini seminyaka emibili, okusho ukuthi abanye abantu abanikezwa izibonelelo zokuqala eziphakeme baqhubeka besebenzisa izinsizakalo zasebhange ezisemthethweni. Kodwa-ke, abanye abantu, labo abanolwazi oluphansi lwezezimali, kungenzeka ukuthi bavule ama-akhawunti asebhange ukuze bathole isibonelelo, futhi kamuva abakaze basebenzise bese bevala ama-akhawunti abo asebhange.


Ngokuyisisekelo angiqiniseki ukuthi ngiyavumelana nesimiso esishiwo ngababhali ukuthi imfundo yezezimali ihloselwe ukuba ibe yithuluzi lokwandisa "ukujula nobubanzi bohlelo lwezezimali." Ngikholelwa ukuthi imfundo yezezimali, ukuyibheka ngombono webhange, iyithuluzi lokusiza ukugqugquzela ukusetshenziswa kwemali nesikweletu okunomthwalo wemfanelo, okuzoletha imiphumela engcono kumuntu ngamunye nasebhange. Ngicabanga ngalokhu njengokunqoba, futhi ngicabanga ukuthi ababhali baqaphele ukuthi banganciphisi imfundo yezezimali iyonke.


Mhlawumbe iphuzu elivelele kakhulu ephepheni, okungenani kimi, lifika lapho ababhali bethi "lo mphumela unemiphumela ebalulekile ekufundeni kwezibonelelo njengethuluzi lokwandisa ukufinyelela kwezezimali: izikhuthazo zezezimali zodwa zingase zinganele ukudonsa imindeni engafundile ohlelweni lwezezimali njengoba le mindeni ingamane ifune izikhuthazo ngaphandle kokusebenzisa izinsizakalo. " Leli yiphuzu elibaluleke kakhulu futhi, mhlawumbe isihloko solunye usuku, lokhu kuhambisana ne- "Lucas Critique" edumile lapho umklomelo weNobel uRobert Lucas echaza isidingo sokufaka ukuthi abantu baziphathe kanjani ngendlela amasu futhi babheke phambili kumamodeli ethu ezomnotho kanye nezilinganiso ezibonakalayo.


Ngokombono wezomnotho kubaluleke kakhulu ukuphenya lezi zinhlobo zemibuzo ukuze sikwazi ukuzama ukubeka izinombolo ezithile ezizuzweni zokusebenzisa izibonelelo kanye nokungenelela kwemfundo yezezimali. Kuyingxenye ye-modus operandi yethu e-Dollar Scholars ukuqapha, ukubuyekeza, ukuhlaziya nokuhlanganisa izincwadi zezemfundo yezezimali ukuletha kangcono izinsizakalo kubahlomuli bethu, nokuletha izixazululo ezingabizi kakhulu futhi ezingabizi kakhulu zokukhulisa ulwazi lwezezimali.


Okubaluleke kakhulu ukuthi ababhali babhekisela kwimfundo yezezimali njengento ebiza kakhulu. Kithina ku-Dollar Scholars, angiqiniseki ukuthi izindleko zabo ze- $ 17 US umuntu ngamunye zokuqeqeshwa kwezezimali zibonakala zinengqondo. Singabantu bezomnotho, ngemuva kwakho konke, futhi kungumsebenzi wethu ukusebenza futhi senze kahle ngaphansi kwezingqinamba eziqinile zezinsizakusebenza. Uma kukhona okuthile, izazi zezomnotho kufanele zazi ukuthi imali nokuxhaswa ngezimali akukhuli ezihlahleni!


Izinkomba

  • Cole, Shawn, Thomas Sampson, and Bilal Zia. 2011. “Prices or knowledge? What drives demand for financial services in emerging markets?” The journal of finance 66 (6): 1933–1967.
  • Klapper, Leora, Annamaria Lusardi, and Peter van Oudheusden. 2015. Financial Literacy Around the World: Insights from the Standard & Poor’s Ratings Services Global Financial Literacy Survey. Standard & Poor’s Ratings Services. https://gflec.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/Finlit_paper_16_F2_singles.pdf.